Forums: Index > The Cathedral > 3 Articles?

  • There are 3 articles for Shin Megami Tensei: Persona, one for the PSP release, another one for the Revelations: Persona release and the last one is for the Japanese release of the game, is this really necessary? The 3 of them are the same game, not the same release, but the same game, wouldn't it be better to merge all of them together as Shin Megami Tensei: Persona, and redirect the Japanese and the PSX release to it, especially since the 3 of this articles are all stubs, it would be a much cleaner way to organize things.
  • I know one thing. There's no way in hell I'm seeing Revelations joined with anything. Great Mara 03:41, October 11, 2010 (UTC)
  • We would be using the names of the characters from the PSP release :P, this 3 articles all basically say the same thing, we would only need to include in the merge the release dates of the other versions.
  • I honestly agree that it's a little ridiculous. Are the differences that vast among them? I know the Revelations article deals more with the differences between the original and the localisation, but those could be discussed in the original article or in an article specifically titled for it. I understand, however, leaving the original and the remake separate, since that was done for Persona 3, but it's not like FES has that much substance to its article, though P3P does. Then again, P3P seems to add a lot of gameplay elements, whereas Persona PSP doesn't seem to if the article is any indication. Either we need to fix that article up, or we need to merge it with the original. But I think we definitely need to merge Revelations with Persona. Treating them like two separate games is a bit much. That's my opinion.
    ~ FangzV ( Flame at me here) as said on 21:18, November 17, 2010 (UTC)