274 Votes in Poll
Yeah, they're chilling with Kazumi Kiba
However, fem!MC was in two games (P3P and PQ2) and in tons of official materials (artbooks and so on). Yeah, _games_ not anime. Haters can hate as much as they want, but if you ask about favourite protagonists, you have to include all of them, not only those you like.
It's 2020 already and people still have this "canon vs non-canon" fights. Like, who cares? She's in a game, she's a playable protagonist. That's all that matters.
First- what year it is has no bearing on anything.
Second- She can be excluded on the grounds that she's not the protagonist in the mainline games, which everyone else is. I get that you like her, which is valid, but she just isn't the Persona 3 protagonist. She's a spinoff protagonist. She has no more claim to the title than Aigis.
Third- nobody is hating her. We were making jokes, and nobody is saying she's a terrible protagonist or that she doesn't deserve to be on the list.
Fourth- Why doesn't the canon matter? I'm genuinely confused on this point. If you mean that it has no bearing on the poll or list, fine. However, the creator of the post excluded her for some reason, and we don't know what. Maybe they meant main line protags only, or maybe they just didn't know about her. If you don't like the poll, make your own.
That sounded really snobbish and awful, so I'm sorry. I don't mean to disparage you; I just tend to get long-winded and wound up when I get going, no matter how small a thing it is.
Where’s best girl FeMC?
Minato? I thought it was makoto?
They have different names. Sometimes it's minato, sometimes it's makoto
None of them have a personality
I mean, Tatsuya is a whole character in EP.
And they all have little bits of personality. For instance, Makoto is pretty quiet and unassuming no matter what you do with him and is inherently morbid due to his apathy over death, while Yu is at bare minimum a pretty responsible guy since he's watching the house by himself a lot in December and January and Dojima doesn't complain about anything.
Maya and Tatsuya are actual characters with personality though, if people had played their games I can assure you they would be on top. Too bad Persona 1 and 2 get memed so hard nobody even try to play them cuz they deserve way more attention than P3+.
What do you think?