Honestly I understand a lot of where you all are coming from with your opinions. It seems P5 was the most liked according to the poll. My personal favorite is P4 because of how much I love the characters (although I can see how Teddie is annoying)
I first played P4 and went back to P3 and found a appreciation for P3 but never really stuck to me (maybe because I didn’t like the ending but I understand it was necessary)
P5 is a fantastic game with its music and visuals but it does have some flaws, and inconsistencies. I hope the DLC will add a lot of new content for us all to enjoy.
Thanks for your discussions this is my first post and I will make sure to continue ^_^
P4 is my favorite due to it helping me get through a tough time and a giving me joy at that time. I also find the gameplay and music to be the best in the franchise. Also the party members is my personal favorite in the franchise.
P3 is amazing and actually got me really emotional due to its amazing story which does not happened to me that often. It story, gameplay, characters and music is absolutely fantastic.
P5 was my first but my least favourite. P5 is only above P1 in term of personal favorite for me. The story was generic and perditable. Whoever thought that every villain should be connected (besides kamoshida) was really stupid or lazy. The music was okay not my favourite genre. I pretty much dislike the whole cast besides Yusuke, Kawakami, Velvet Twins and the shogi player (forgot the name). The MC felt bland and felt like he had no say in anything (morgana pretty much always spoke for you and force to due stuff even if you said no). And the fans did not help with them constantly praising it and raining hell on you if you had any criticism.
P4 was my first persona game, but not my favourite. I played P3 after finishing P4 - and, ooh boy, was my mind blown. I suppose you could argue that the P3 cast isn't as relatable as the P4 and P5 cast - but out of all the persona games, I felt most connected to the P3 cast. Also, my emo kid self just loves the P3 soundtrack and art direction. Sure, it might be the least pretty (as far as graphics go), but the story and the character hold a special place in my heart.
TL;DR: Persona 3 all the way.
Yeah when I went back and played I love the emo direction of the story (if that makes any sense) Although the visuals weren’t there since it is old, P3 will always have a special place in my heart.
I love the ones I played which was Persona 3 Portable and 4 golden. I spent over 100 hours on 3 and about 85 on 4. What kept me playing was the music. I honestly have to say both plots were good. But Persona 3 was my first, it felt much more emotional, the music made feel even more emotional. I liked the character design more than persona 4 as well. Except Kens persona, especially his evolved one. As for the ending I was much more satisfied with Golden's ending than 3. Don't get me wrong , I liked the ending, It made me cry, but I didn't feel satisfied, I wanted more, which I think the Answer will fix that(As soon as I get my hands on FES). But yeah, both have their pros and cons. As for 5, haven't played it yet, music's alright
There are 6 persona games and not included the first 3 is sacrilege
Where are the good ones? I don’t see any of the good ones. Why can’t I vote for Innocent Sin?
I didn’t include the original 3 because of Atlas disowning them and not being so relevant now.
Persona 3 Portable is my introductory game to the franchise, hence I still keep it close to my heart. Persona 5 is my close, close second.
Hey didn’t 5 lack in story because of the events that happened to Japan in 2011 and so atlus decided to scrap the original and had to hurry for the launch date
What do you think?